oh totally get stuck on those sometimes. depends a bit on the vibe you're going for, but here's a few i use:
* 'leave a lasting mark' (good for something significant)
* 'stand out to' (if it's about being noticed among others)
* 'resonate with' (more about emotional or intellectual connection)
* 'have an impact on' (general, but works well)
* 'get noticed by' (if it's more superficial)
what kinda impression are you trying to describe?